Sunday, January 30, 2011

#4 - Mario Lemieux

Mario Lemieux (Murillo Pyramid Rank = #4)

Adjusted Stats

1984-1985 Pit          75 GP   35 goals   46 assists   81 points   1.08 PPG
1985-1986 Pit          81 GP   38 goals   74 assists   112 points 1.38 PPG
1986-1987 Pit          65 GP   46 goals   45 assists   92 points   1.43 PPG
1987-1988 Pit          79 GP   59 goals   83 assists   142 points 1.81 PPG
1988-1989 Pit          78 GP   72 goals   96 assists   168 points 2.16 PPG
1989-1990 Pit          60 GP   39 goals   67 assists   106 points 1.75 PPG
1990-1991 Pit*        27 GP   17 goals   24 assists   41 points   1.54 PPG
1991-1992 Pit*        66 GP   40 goals   79 assists   119 points 1.81 PPG
1992-1993 Pit          59 GP   58 goals   75 assists   133 points 2.27 PPG
1993-1994 Pit          21 GP   16 goals   19 assists   34 points   1.59 PPG
1995-1996 Pit          70 GP   67 goals   90 assists   157 points 2.24 PPG
1996-1997 Pit          76 GP   53 goals   76 assists   129 points 1.70 PPG
2000-2001 Pit          43 GP   39 goals   46 assists   85 points   1.98 PPG
2001-2002 Pit          24 GP   7 goals     29 assists   36 points   1.50 PPG
2002-2003 Pit          67 GP   32 goals   73 assists   105 points 1.57 PPG
2003-2004 Pit          10 GP   1 goal      10 assists   11 points   1.10 PPG
2005-2006 Pit          26 GP   7 goals     15 assists   22 points   0.86 PPG

Adjusted Playoff Stats

1988-1989 Pit          11 GP    10 goals   6 assists    16 points    1.48 PPG
1990-1991 Pit*        23 GP    14 goals   24 assists  38 points    1.63 PPG
1991-1992 Pit*        15 GP    14 goals   16 assists  30 points    1.98 PPG
1992-1993 Pit          11 GP    7 goals     8 assists    15 points    1.34 PPG
1993-1994 Pit          6 GP      4 goals     3 assists    7 points      1.15 PPG
1995-1996 Pit          18 GP    11 goals   15 assists  26 points    1.43 PPG
1996-1997 Pit          5 GP      3 goals     3 assists    6 points      1.26 PPG
2000-2001 Pit          18 GP    7 goals     13 assists  20 points    1.11 PPG

Career - 927 GP, 626 goals, 947 assists, 1573 points, 1.70 PPG
Career-Highs - 72 goals (88-89); 96 assists (88-89); 168 points (88-89); 2.27 PPG (92-93)
Avg. (17 seasons) - 55 GP, 37 goals, 56 assists, 93 points, 1.70 PPG
Peak Avg. (87-96) - 57 GP, 46 goals, 67 assists, 113 points, 1.97 PPG, 2 Cups

Playoff Career - 107 GP, 70 goals, 88 assists, 158 points, 1.48 PPG
Playoff-Highs - 14 goals (91-92); 24 assists (90-91); 38 points (90-91); 1.98 PPG (91-92)

Accolades - 3 MVP awards, 6 Art Ross, Calder, 2 Conn Smythes
All-Star teams - 5-time 1st-team, 4-time 2nd-team
2-time Stanley Cup Champion

I still vividly remember the day in late 2000 when the early rumblings started breaking: Mario Lemieux was coming back?!? Huh? Really? It started off as a fanciful idea, then he was training and it was looking like it was a little more believable, and then the week came, and Mario circled the calendar for the matchup against the Toronto Maple Leafs...after Christmas, on December 27th. I had my doubts about whether Mario would look out-of-place. It had been three and a half years since he last played.

Well, Mario delivered his answer pretty swiftly, leading the Penguins alongside his linemate Jaromir Jagr to a 5-0 rout of the Leafs, and notching a goal and two assists in the process. Lemieux went on to average nearly two points per game (adjusted), a remarkable feat that left little doubt in my mind that I was lucky enough to be witnessing one of the all-time greats.

Mario Lemieux is the best player I ever saw play. Well, Gretzky is the best I ever saw play, but when I started watching hockey in the mid-90s, Gretzky was nearing his end, while Lemieux was still dominating. It is arguable that Lemieux might be the most talented player to ever play the game (only Orr and Gretzky are in the discussion). The facts:

- His adjusted career scoring average of 1.70 PPG is the best in history, besting Gretzky's 1.64
- His 0.68 adjuted GPG rate would be the best in history if it weren't for Howie Morenz...who, great as he was, played while Herbert Hoover was failing to ward off the Great Depression. Just saying.
- In four seasons, he averaged nearly a goal per game.
- In three, he averaged more than two points a game.
- His 2.27 PPG average in 1992-1993 is the highest anyone has ever achieved.

Sadly, for Lemieux, despite his awe-inspiring averages, there was always the issue of health. Even in his peak years, he only averaged 57 games played, and that's not even factoring in the 1994-1995 season, which he missed completely.

There was also something less tangible: the feeling that Lemieux left something in the tank, particularly early in his career. Even though the numbers for his first five seasons are remarkable, Lemieux battled the stigma of a moody star who wasn't fully committed to hockey (this may have been an inaccurate and unfair perception, but it existed nonetheless). You often hear the phrase "If Mario had wanted to, he could have torn up the record books". You never hear that with Gretzky.

That's why, in the end, the nod has to go to Gretzky in the debate...Gretzky scored at a Lemieux-like pace, except for a Gretzky-like length of time. But just because he has to defer to Gretzky as the greatest scorer of all time doesn't mean that Lemieux should be remembered as anything but one of the most dominant players to ever grace the ice.

One last thought, just for some historical perspective, about Lemieux: any time you hear someone criticizing a player like, say, Ovechkin or whomever for "not being able to win the big one", remember that Lemieux for the first five or six years of his career suffered from the same criticism...and Yzerman and Sakic suffered from it for even longer. Yes, Lemieux was ultra-talented and put up huge numbers, the critics said, but he was selfish, moody, unpredictable, not a true leader. In his first four seasons, the Penguins were a laughingstock who missed the playoffs.

Well, it's a wonder what two Stanley Cup rings can do to silence the critics. From 1990 to 1992, Lemieux put up two of the best playoff performances ever seen, winning two consecutive Conn Smythes and putting up adjusted numbers of 28 goals and 68 points in 38 games. Now we correctly view Lemieux as one of the rarified four who has ever graced the ice (along with Gretzky, Orr and Howe), and I can think of no one better to have as the cutoff point for the Pantheon of hockey superstars.

No comments:

Post a Comment